Director's Cut

The scene they wish they had directed

Spike Lee

The greatest closing shot is in Billy Wilder's Ace In The Hole, where Kirk Douglas drops dead in front of the camera. Billy Wilder! His work is amazing. Another scene is Elia Kazan's On The Waterfront where Brando has to walk to the line-up. I'm very glad that I'm friends with Waterfront screenwriter Budd Shulberg. And then there's the 'Tonight' quartet in West Side Story

Bryan Singer

Close Encounters Of The Third Kind when the alien mothership lands. It's one of the great commercial art movies of all time. The scene tells a magnificent story while at the same time not really telling us what is going on. It is speaking through music. You don't know why the spaceship has taken the people, why it is returning them. You don't know who the aliens are. You don't understand any of those things, but for some reason it all seems to make sense. You feel an experience rather than being told what it is you should think or feel. But I have to admit that it is partly born out of my love of special effects and a fascination with life on other planets.

Michael Mann

I'd like to have done the war room scenes with those spectacular sets in Dr Strangelove and I would change nothing. I especially like all the stuff with Peter Sellers. I just crack up whenever I see it. I just marvel at it. It's a brilliant combination of a sense of doom and foreboding and dark comedy at the same time. It's so extreme and out there. There's such spectacular invention happening. I'd also probably have liked to do the last scene in Casablanca and again I'd have changed nothing.

Director's Cut

This article appeared in the Observer on Sunday February 06 2000 . It was last updated at 18:37 on February 04 2000.

Film and cinema search

Find a film

Latest reviews

  • DVD of the week: [Rec]

  • While the premise might be nothing new there's plenty to be afraid of as the body count rises and the morbid scares come thick and fast

More film reviews

Guardian Jobs

UK

Browse all jobs

USA

  • Associate Producer

    we are seeking a full-time associate producer. this position provides a great foot in the door at the top-rated television news station. youll learn to navigate... . ak.

  • Media Production Position

    in the university catalog. ability to teach audio and/or video post or new media production would enhance the applicant's application. all candidates minimally... . al.

  • Arts, Media & Music Opportunities

    giving you the skills to succeed in the army—and in life. art / media / music art, media & music positions cover the administration, communication and... . de.

Browse all jobs